Typical Cost of a House in Carroll County, Indiana
On this page
The median home value in Carroll County is $180,900, measured over 2020–2024. That is 17.1% below the Indiana median of $218,200. Half of owner-occupied homes are valued above that figure and half below.
Median home value
$180,900
2020–2024, give or take $9,199
Against Indiana
−17.1%
BelowIndiana $218,200
Against the U.S.
−45.6%
BelowU.S. $332,700
Monthly housing costs in Carroll County
What households actually pay each month, for those who own with a mortgage and those who rent, compared with Indiana as a whole.
Owning with a mortgage
$1,190a month
−15.2%Indiana $1,404
Median of mortgage payments, property taxes, insurance, utilities and fees together.
Renting
$890a month
−16.2%Indiana $1,062
Median gross rent: the rent itself plus utilities the renter pays.
Where Carroll County sits among Indiana's counties
Each tick is one county's median home value. The highlighted band holds the middle half of them, and the dark line is the median. Carroll County is the 45th highest of 92.
What this figure is
It is not a sale price. The Census Bureau asks homeowners what they think their home would sell for, and this is the middle answer for owner-occupied homes in Carroll County. It covers every kind of home people own and live in, so the price of a particular house on the market can be far from it.
The figure describes the whole of 2020–2024, not a single year, and it is not adjusted for price changes since then. The smaller a county, the fewer households the survey reaches and the less exact its estimate: here the true value is very likely within $9,199 of the one shown.
Common questions
How much does a house cost in Carroll County, Indiana?
- The median home value in Carroll County, Indiana is $180,900, from Census Bureau survey data for 2020–2024. Half of owner-occupied homes are valued above that and half below.
What is the average home price in Carroll County, Indiana?
- The Census Bureau publishes a median rather than an average: $180,900 for 2020–2024. It is what owners estimate their homes would sell for, not a record of recent sale prices.
How much is a monthly mortgage payment in Carroll County, Indiana?
- Homeowners with a mortgage in Carroll County, Indiana pay a median of $1,190 a month. That covers the mortgage payment together with property taxes, insurance and utilities.
What is the average rent in Carroll County, Indiana?
- Median gross rent in Carroll County, Indiana is $890 a month for 2020–2024. Gross rent is the rent itself plus the utilities the renter pays.
Are homes in Carroll County, Indiana expensive compared with other places?
- Carroll County has the 45th highest median home value of the 92 counties in Indiana with a published figure, 17.1% below the Indiana median of $218,200.
Source
U.S. Census Bureau
American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, 2020–2024, tables B25077, B25064 and B25088. Retrieved on October 6, 2026.
About the American Community SurveySource: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-Year Estimates, 2020–2024.
Other counties in Indiana
The percentage compares each county with the Indiana median.
- Adams County−18.2%$178,400
- Allen County−1.5%$214,900
- Bartholomew County+6.7%$232,800
- Benton County−30.8%$151,000
- Blackford County−50.7%$107,500
- Boone County+72.4%$376,200
- Brown County+23.3%$269,100
- Cass County−38.7%$133,800
- Clark County+2.2%$222,900
- Clay County−29.9%$153,000
- Clinton County−24.8%$164,100
- Crawford County−46.1%$117,700
- Daviess County−9.6%$197,200
- Dearborn County+11.5%$243,400
- Decatur County−8.8%$199,100
- DeKalb County−11.0%$194,100
- Delaware County−36.1%$139,400
- Dubois County+5.5%$230,100
- Elkhart County−3.6%$210,400
- Fayette County−40.1%$130,700
- Floyd County+15.0%$251,000
- Fountain County−34.3%$143,400
- Franklin County+14.3%$249,500
- Fulton County−28.3%$156,500
- Gibson County−17.5%$180,000
- Grant County−44.0%$122,300
- Greene County−29.8%$153,200
- Hamilton County+85.8%$405,500
- Hancock County+25.9%$274,800
- Harrison County+5.2%$229,600
- Hendricks County+41.0%$307,600
- Henry County−29.2%$154,400
- Howard County−24.4%$165,000
- Huntington County−25.9%$161,600
- Jackson County−18.3%$178,300
- Jasper County+1.5%$221,500
- Jay County−46.2%$117,500
- Jefferson County−10.8%$194,600
- Jennings County−26.0%$161,500
- Johnson County+30.4%$284,600
- Knox County−36.9%$137,700
- Kosciusko County−1.0%$216,000
- LaGrange County+17.3%$255,900
- Lake County+5.7%$230,600
- LaPorte County−10.4%$195,500
- Lawrence County−19.8%$175,000
- Madison County−26.1%$161,300
- Marion County+2.7%$224,000
- Marshall County−6.1%$204,900
- Martin County−26.9%$159,400
- Miami County−42.2%$126,200
- Monroe County+30.7%$285,200
- Montgomery County−21.3%$171,800
- Morgan County+8.9%$237,600
- Newton County−21.4%$171,500
- Noble County−9.8%$196,800
- Ohio County−2.3%$213,100
- Orange County−27.3%$158,700
- Owen County−21.0%$172,400
- Parke County−30.7%$151,200
- Perry County−25.1%$163,400
- Pike County−29.0%$154,900
- Porter County+29.0%$281,500
- Posey County+2.2%$222,900
- Pulaski County−28.3%$156,400
- Putnam County+0.3%$218,900
- Randolph County−48.0%$113,400
- Ripley County+2.0%$222,500
- Rush County−23.6%$166,800
- Scott County−27.4%$158,400
- Shelby County−2.7%$212,400
- Spencer County−15.1%$185,200
- St. Joseph County−11.6%$192,800
- Starke County−27.7%$157,700
- Steuben County−0.9%$216,200
- Sullivan County−39.9%$131,100
- Switzerland County−19.4%$175,800
- Tippecanoe County+9.7%$239,300
- Tipton County−20.0%$174,600
- Union County−20.5%$173,500
- Vanderburgh County−15.7%$184,000
- Vermillion County−48.2%$113,100
- Vigo County−31.9%$148,500
- Wabash County−28.0%$157,200
- Warren County−16.4%$182,500
- Warrick County+11.1%$242,500
- Washington County−21.1%$172,200
- Wayne County−35.7%$140,200
- Wells County−9.4%$197,600
- White County−19.4%$175,900
- Whitley County+0.5%$219,400